[Peugeot-L] XN6 cooked antifreeze smell

From: kenneth parker <elkeni_at_mac.com>
Date: 07/10/05

        Some months ago billows of white smoke caused me to pressurize my cooling system (Stant ST-255) and discover a lot of coolant leaking into cylinder #2. The head was removed and the head gasket was carefully scrutinized for any holes/defects, etc. Nothing apparent was found. I had the head pressure tested and a crack -I believe it was internal, not in a firing chamber- was found. I bought a used head, with enough meat on it, that passed the pressure test and had it resurfaced and had the valves and seats done.

        I did a surgical reassembly, though I used a Snap-on click stop wrench for torquing the head instead of the manual recommended torque angle gauge. The head bolts were wire brushed prior to assembly and their respective holes in the block were chased (not chaste) and, again, surgically cleaned out with compressed air. The bolts were torqued at 60 ft. lbs., and the head re-torqued at 600 miles.

        For some days everything seemed problem free and then I began to detect the smell of cooked antifreeze. I looked and looked but could not find an apparent leak, though I needed to add .5 quart of coolant to the system every couple of days. No smoke from the tail pipe, but the smell was there. I did not detect the smell at the tail pipe, but in the engine compartment.

        A Peugeot guy in Alameda, Sam from SK Auto, put it up in the air and looked at the rear of the head (by the manifold down pipe). He noticed some discoloration on the block just below the rear of the head and said that he thought it was a bad head gasket. He told me to clean it off (the block under the head), and spray paint it and then run it and look at it again. Sam told me that it was probably not the right brand head gasket (It was a Curty Payen) and said that he bought his from a guy in Texas (I assumed Madhu from Disortex). He suggested that I re-torque the head at least five additional lbs. to 65.

        I think Brian Holm suggested that I drain the block before retorquing the head. I drained the block and retorqued the head to 65 ft. lbs. I re-adjusted the valves and put a couple of GM cooling system tabs in the radiator. Everything seemed fine and the coolant level seemed pretty stable. After a month of driving I, again, started to smell cooked coolant. The smell was apparent only sometimes after driving. The coolant loss is very slight, like a cup or two every four or five days.

        This problem has been driving me nuts. There are times that I think I can detect the smell of antifreeze at the tail pipe and times when I can't.

        I was wondering if anyone out there had any suggestions -other than seeing a therapist- that they might be kind enough to send my way.

        Again, the coolant loss is minimal and the smell is apparent after I drive my daughter to school (20 minutes non-freeway) or am idling after a brisk freeway run. The smell seems to be present at the tail pipe only some of the time. I put a lot of work into this car and am thoroughly demoralized with it and looking for a BMW 325is to elevate my spirits.
Desperate in California,
Ken

Recommended format for your email subject lines: Model # [Model Letters] Year Subject

Examples:
505 88 V6 Mileage
405 Mi16 89 Ignition Coil source?



To unsubscribe from this list send a blank email message to PEUGEOT-L-UNSUBSCRIBE@EGROUPS.COM
 

Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:

    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/peugeot-L/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:

    peugeot-L-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:

    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/   Received on Sun Jul 10 02:10:52 2005